Organic sourdough
Our pizza crust and sub bread are made with organic sourdough—long-fermented for real flavor, not a shortcut dough.
100% Fresh Long-Ferment Sourdough
Best Sourdough Pizza in Chesterland, OH
Organic sourdough pizza & subs · Fried in 100% beef tallow · Pickup & delivery
You want pizza night done right—real crust, real ingredients, still hot when it hits the table.
What makes us different
100% beef tallow fry
Wings, tenders, and fried sides are cooked in 100% beef tallow—not seed oils—for crispier, cleaner-tasting food.
Tired of pizza that tastes like cardboard?
Most “quick” pizza forces a tradeoff: fast and forgettable, or good and a hassle. You shouldn’t have to choose.
The usual options
Chain pies, frozen crusts, and mystery toppings that leave you full but not satisfied.
What you actually want
You want dinner to feel like a win—something you’re proud to put in front of family or friends.
What you deserve
People who care about food deserve pizza made with time, olive oil, and ingredients that actually taste like food.
Sourdough pizza worth the drive
Very Good Pizza Co. serves Chesterland and nearby Gates Mills, Kirtland, Chagrin Falls, and Mayfield with organic sourdough crust pizza—and the same organic sourdough in our sub bread— made the slow way with olive oil and heritage flour.
From dirty wings and jumbo wings (fried in 100% beef tallow) to Italian, meatball, jerk, and BBQ chicken subs—plus calzones, salads, and pasta—we’re the local spot for pickup and delivery when you want food that actually tastes handmade.
Order now
Fastest path: order online for pickup or delivery.
Also available on DoorDash (Very Good Pizza Company – Chesterland).
We’ve got Chesterland’s pizza night covered
We get it
We know the Friday scramble: hungry kids, guests on the way, and zero patience for a mediocre pie. You want something better than “good enough.”
Why neighbors trust us
We’re Very Good Pizza Co.—organic sourdough pizza & subs, wings and fries cooked in 100% beef tallow, and 410+ Google reviews from neighbors who keep coming back.
Three easy steps to pizza night
-
Pick your pie
Browse specialty sourdough pizzas, wings, subs, and more on our menu.
-
Order online
Checkout on UpMenu for pickup or delivery—fastest path from craving to crust.
-
Dig in
Hot, handmade pizza on Chillicothe Road (or at your door)—no compromise required.
Menu favorites
Crowd-pleasers from our Chesterland kitchen—built for hungry locals and weekend takeout.
Pizza Deluxe
Sausage, pepperoni, onion, mushrooms, green peppers on our sourdough crust.
Veggie Belle
Roasted red peppers, olives, mushrooms, peppers & onions—fresh and loaded.
Meat Monster
Pepperoni, sausage, ham, salami & bacon for serious meat lovers.
Cheesy Garlic Bread
Homemade bread piled high with Provolone and Mozzarella—customer favorite.
What locals say
Real 5-star Google reviews for Very Good Pizza Co. in Chesterland.
★★★★★
Had an excellent order tonight! My 4 yr old son rated the pizza 57 stars out of 5 stars. We've been ordering from here (and the old location) since moving to the area in 2019. I like the sourdough pizza dough, it adds a nice complexity to the pizza flavor. The Ohio style had a great undercarriage but I wish it was a tad more crispy. The wings were perfectly cooked. Also got an order of sourdough donuts and they were better than the Patterson Fruit Farm donuts we had earlier in the day.
Google review
★★★★★
Absolutely amazing pizza. exactly what i was looking for when i stopped in. i have been searching for good pizza with thin good sourdough crust for a while. the crust is really good and real food ingredients not artificial bs like dominos or pizza hut. It's affordable aswell. and super amazing service. i was given a free drink aswell for my first visit as i didnt have cash and the card machine charges more then the drink to operate in chesterland not the stores decision. But overall pizza rating 8/10. Would be a 10/10 if i had communicated i wasn't a big cheese fan and to to go lighter. I got a slice with spinach for 2$ and filled me up for lunch. GOOD PIZZA AND GOOD SERVICE. GOOD PRICES TOO. will be back forever now as i was treated amazing my first time.
Google review
★★★★★
A big thank you to Very Good Pizza Co. Chesterland for helping me and my team bring some "spirit" into our office during spirit week! Our employees absolutely loved the variety of pizzas and the delicious salad we ordered. A special shoutout to Bob for delivering everything right to our downtown office – and the pizza was still hot! If you're planning a pizza order for your next event, I highly recommend checking out Very Good Pizza Company! You won't be disappointed!
Google review
★★★★★
Saw the $2 slice sign out on 306 and decided to stop in for lunch. I was very impressed by both the size and quality of the slices. The sourdough base was light and crisp and the slice was perfect for folding. My son said it was the best pizza he's ever had. I'll definitely be back - one of the best values in Geauga County!
Google review
★★★★★
Finally a pizza company that puts forth the extra effort and money to use real food and ingredients. In today's world of so many food companies adding just a touch of poison, this is a treasure. A health conscious movement even. Let others follow their lead and maybe we can cut back our sad contributions to the cancer industry. Delicious pizza that doesn't make you feel sick, tired and bloated afterwards. Atmosphere: Clean, cozy and welcoming. A nice environment to take a time out, sit down and enjoy. Staff: Kind, professional and cheerful. 5+ Stars!
Google review
★★★★★
My boyfriend and I came here for dinner and had a great experience. The pizza was amazing, so good and so fresh. The crust was impeccable. The service was outstanding and everyone was so kind and helpful. Would definitely recommend!!
Google review
Don’t settle for another forgettable delivery
One more bland chain order means another night that feels like a chore—and leftovers nobody fights over.
Real pizza. Happy table. Easy night.
Organic sourdough pizza and subs, dirty wings fried in beef tallow, and food that tastes handmade—so pizza night feels special again in Chesterland.
Hours & location
Visit us on Chillicothe Road or order for pickup & delivery across Geauga and eastern Cuyahoga.
Visit & contact
Very Good Pizza Co.
12720 Chillicothe Road
Chesterland, Ohio 44026
Hours
Monday – Wednesday11am – 8pm
Thursday11am – 9pm
Friday – Saturday11am – 10pm
Sunday12pm – 8pm
Contact us
Questions about catering, large orders, or anything else? Send a note — we’ll get back to you.
Hungry in Chesterland?
Order sourdough pizza, wings, and subs for pickup or delivery.
Make tonight the easy win—real crust, real flavor, ordered in minutes.