About Very Good Pizza Co.
A Chesterland pizzeria built on organic sourdough pizza & subs, 100% beef tallow frying, and local flavor.
Very Good Pizza Co. is home to organic sourdough pizza and organic sourdough subs in Chesterland, Ohio. We make our dough the slow way—with time, olive oil, and organic flour—so every pie and sub has character you won’t get from a frozen crust or a rushed chain. Our wings and fried sides? Cooked in 100% beef tallow—not seed oils.
We’re on Chillicothe Road serving Chesterland and neighbors in Gates Mills, Kirtland, Chagrin Falls, Mayfield, Novelty, and towns across Geauga and eastern Cuyahoga. Whether you’re grabbing pickup after work or ordering delivery for pizza night, we’re here for hungry locals who care how their food is made.
Why sourdough?
Long fermentation develops flavor and texture that short-rise doughs can’t match. Our crust is the foundation— then we load specialty pies, build-your-own creations, calzones, and more. Pair a Mediterranean or Meat Monster with dirty wings, jumbo wings, or an Italian, meatball, jerk, or BBQ chicken sub.
- Organic sourdough — pizza crust and sub bread, long-fermented and handmade.
- 100% beef tallow — we fry wings and sides in beef tallow, not seed oils.
- Olive oil & organic flour — ingredients you can taste.
- Full menu — pizza, dirty wings, appetizers, calzones, salads, subs & pasta.
- Pickup & delivery — order online via UpMenu; DoorDash available as a secondary option.
Local pizza for Chesterland & beyond
From Chester Township and Russell Township to Mayfield Heights, Pepper Pike, Bainbridge, and Chardon, we’re proud to be the sourdough pizza spot nearby when you want something better than ordinary delivery. Follow us on Instagram and Facebook for specials and kitchen updates.
Visit us at 12720 Chillicothe Road, Chesterland, Ohio 44026, call 440-729-9300, or email verygoodpizzaco@gmail.com.
We don’t just sell pizza—we help you win dinner
You’re the hero of pizza night. We’re the local guide with the long-ferment sourdough plan.
We get dinner stress
You want food that tastes intentional—not another interchangeable delivery box.
Here's how we help
Slow dough, olive oil, heritage flour, and a full menu of wings, calzones, salads, and subs—built for Chesterland locals.
Taste the difference
Organic sourdough · Beef tallow fry · Wings · Subs — Chesterland, OH · Sun open noon